For years I’ve been continuously fighting with backups. I have not been particularly good or consistent at it. We’ve been okay with Time Machine and Carbon Copy Cloner, but the recent addition of a digital SLR to our gadget collection has meant running out of space on our shared home drive.
Historically I’d been using a WD My Book 2×1 TB RAID1 array connected to an Apple Airport Extreme and shared via AirDisk (afp). We had Time Machine backup all the computers in the house in the AirDisk. We’d also store our photos and videos, etc. in the AirDisk. Aside running out of space, we had no good offsite strategy. Given that our digital picture collection is continuously becoming more and more valuable as a family history artifact, I though it was time to address this properly, rather than just adding more space.
I started by classifying the risk associated with each data type:
- Personal files: document scans, photos, videos, etc. This is the critical part of the equation. In case of fire or theft we’d have no replacement and the loss would be HUGE.
- Shared Media: movies, music, etc. These are regrettable if lost, but can be restore. I know how to find them back, even though it might be painful or costly.
- Backups: the time machine backups from our home computers. Since we have the laptops plus the backup, I was not too worried about losing this.
Since no all data is born equal, the required reliability levels vary. For personal files, I want to be covered against hardware failures. For the other kinds, I don’t mind that much.
Additionally, for videos, I want to have the ability to connect the storage unit directly to my computer while editing (my experience editing over the network has not been great).
Finally, I really wanted an offsite backup for our personal data.
Given these constrains, I struggled to find a good (cost-effective) combination, and since I think I’ve found something that works well for me, I thought I’d share with others just in case this helps:
- Airport Extreme Station 802.11n 2nd Generation (100/1000) (any 1 Gbps switch would do).
- Buffalo LinkStation Pro Duo 2×3 TB (NAS), connected to AES via 1 Gbps ethernet. Setup as RAID1 and exposing two afp shares (Personal, Media) and a Time Machine ‘Backup’ share that each computer uses to create a separate sparsebundle.
- 2x WD My Book 2×1 TB on RAID0, mounted ‘usbdisk’, connected via USB to LinkStation and used to backup incrementally every night from the NAS internal disks. Every week I rotate the USB WD drive units between office and home.
- If I want to edit video, I unmount the USB drive and connect via Firewire to my computer for doing video edits. When I mount it back, I manually copy the edits back to the NAS internal drives. This is the only manual step in the process.
- The media files are exposed through the embedded server in the LinkStation via UPnP and iTunes Server. This allows me to use Boxee on any computer (and a patched Apple TV 2nd gen) to watch our videos. We also share iTunes music this way without having to share libraries.
I ended up putting all the data under RAID1, but I think the cost is low since we mostly only read from the array (except the backups). With this setup:
- We have Time Machine for all computers in the house, happening over the network and transparently.
- We can access all data both via afp mounts as well as directly via USB/FW for intensive reads / edits.
- We have an offsite copy.
Overall, I am happy with the setup. I was initially worried about using a home-grade NAS, but even though the LS is slow for writes, it’s actually fast for reads, so I am happy.